← All tier lists

Makeup Brands, Ranked

From cult-classic bullets to the clearance-bin regret pile.

Ranked on product quality, cultural impact, shade range, and value — legacy houses and viral disruptors judged by the same brush.
✦ Disagree? Make your own →
S
MAC Cosmetics
MAC Cosmetics
The pro-artist standard

Founded in Toronto in 1984 and now owned by Estée Lauder, MAC is the backbone of pro makeup kits with Ruby Woo and Studio Fix as genuine industry benchmarks.

Shop MAC Cosmetics →
Charlotte Tilbury
Charlotte Tilbury
Pillow Talk empire

Launched in 2013 by the celebrity makeup artist, its Pillow Talk lineup and Flawless Filter primer became runaway bestsellers, and Puig acquired a majority stake in a deal valuing it near £1.2 billion.

Shop Charlotte Tilbury →
Fenty Beauty
Fenty Beauty
The 40-shade revolution

Rihanna's 2017 launch debuted Pro Filt'r foundation in 40 shades, forcing the whole industry toward inclusivity in what became known as the 'Fenty effect.'

Shop Fenty Beauty →
A
NARS
NARS
Orgasm blush icon

François Nars founded the brand in 1994, and its Orgasm blush and Radiant Creamy Concealer remain perennial best-sellers and staff-favorite cult classics.

Shop NARS →
Dior Beauty
Dior Beauty
Luxury done right

The LVMH-owned line pairs prestige branding with genuinely strong products — Dior Addict Lip Glow and Forever foundation are consistent top luxury sellers.

Shop Dior Beauty →
Rare Beauty
Rare Beauty
Selena's soft-matte hit

Selena Gomez's 2020 brand went viral for its Soft Pinch Liquid Blush, and it pairs commercial success with a mental-health-focused mission via the Rare Impact Fund.

Shop Rare Beauty →
Urban Decay
Urban Decay
Naked palette legend

Its Naked eyeshadow palettes and All Nighter setting spray defined 2010s makeup, and the brand helped mainstream long-wear neutral-toned eye looks.

Shop Urban Decay →
e.l.f. Cosmetics
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Drugstore value MVP

e.l.f. delivers dupe-quality products at rock-bottom prices — its Halo Glow filter and Power Grip primer drove double-digit sales growth and repeated Super Bowl ad buys.

Shop e.l.f. Cosmetics →
B
Maybelline
Maybelline
Sky High reliability

The L'Oréal-owned mass brand owns the mascara aisle, with Sky High and Lash Sensational among the best-selling mascaras in the world.

Shop Maybelline →
NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup
TikTok's affordable go-to

This L'Oréal-owned line thrives on social media with viral hits like the Fat Oil Lip Drip and Butter Gloss at consistently low price points.

Shop NYX Professional Makeup →
Benefit Cosmetics
Benefit Cosmetics
Brow-bar specialist

The LVMH-owned brand dominates the brow category and its Hoola bronzer and They're Real mascara are steady sellers, though its playful line leans gimmicky.

Shop Benefit Cosmetics →
Estée Lauder
Estée Lauder
Double Wear heritage

The 1946-founded house anchors a beauty conglomerate, and its Double Wear foundation is a genuine long-wear classic despite an aging brand image.

Shop Estée Lauder →
L'Oréal Paris
L'Oréal Paris
Because you're worth it

The flagship of the world's largest cosmetics company delivers dependable drugstore staples like True Match foundation and Voluminous mascara at scale.

Shop L'Oréal Paris →
C
Milani
Milani
The affordable dupe king

A drugstore value pick whose Baked Blush in Luminoso is a famous budget alternative to NARS Orgasm, though its overall range is uneven.

Shop Milani →
CoverGirl
CoverGirl
Easy, breezy, fading

A storied American drugstore brand that has lost cultural relevance in recent years, with formulas that feel dated next to newer budget rivals.

Shop CoverGirl →
Revlon
Revlon
ColorStay survivor

The ColorStay line still performs, but the parent company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2022, underscoring how far the once-dominant brand has slipped.

Shop Revlon →
D
Rimmel London
Rimmel London
Get the London look

Once a Kate Moss-fronted drugstore staple, it has faded in the US market and its formulas rarely compete with modern budget brands like e.l.f.

Shop Rimmel London →
Wet n Wild
Wet n Wild
Cheap for a reason

Extreme affordability occasionally yields a viral product, but consistency is poor and much of the range reflects its rock-bottom pricing.

Shop Wet n Wild →
F
Jeffree Star Cosmetics
Jeffree Star Cosmetics
Talent buried by scandal

Despite well-reviewed liquid lipsticks, the brand is inseparable from its founder's long record of racist remarks and public feuds that cratered retail partnerships and reputation.

Shop Jeffree Star Cosmetics →

As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases.

◆ Ranked on Tier Deck · browse all 296 lists · Privacy · Terms